Case Information

19-2-05859-34 | LOUIS GILLESPIE, III vs THURSTON COUNTY

Case Number
19-2-05859-34

Court
Thurston

Judicial Officer
Murphy, Carol

File Date
11/27/2019

Case Type
TMV Tort – Motor Vehicle

Case Status
Active

Party

Plaintiff
GILLESPIE, LOUIS, III

Active Attorneys

Attorney

Fong, Eric Michael

Retained

---

Lead Attorney

JAMES, KAMELA J

Retained

---

---

Defendant
THURSTON COUNTY

Active Attorneys

Attorney

Dynan, Mark J.

Retained

---

Lead Attorney

Peters, Donald R., Jr

Retained

---

Attorney

Behar, Samuel Ben

Retained

---

Events and Hearings

• 1 11/27/2019 Case Information Cover Sheet View Document Case Information Cover Sheet
• 2 11/27/2019 Summons View Document Summons
• 3 11/27/2019 Complaint View Document Complaint
• 4 11/27/2019 Notice of Assignment View Document Notice of Assignment
• 5 12/16/2019 Notice of Appearance View Document Notice of Appearance
• 6 12/16/2019 Affidavit Declaration Certificate Confirmation of Service View Document Affidavit Declaration Certificate Confirmation of Service
• 7 12/19/2019 Notice of Association of Counsel View Document Notice of Association of Counsel
• 8 12/23/2019 Notice View Document Notice Comment
  of Firm Name Change
• 9 02/25/2020 Answer View Document Answer
• 10 03/03/2020 Answer View Document Answer
• 11 03/12/2020 Response View Document Response Comment
  Scheduling Questionnaire
• 12 03/16/2020 Demand for Jury 12 Person View Document Demand for Jury 12 Person
• 13 03/24/2020 Response View Document Response Comment
  Scheduling Questionnaire
• 03/27/2020 Assignment for Trial Setting Judicial Officer
  Murphy, Carol Hearing Time
  9:00 AM
• 14 04/06/2020 Order Setting Case Schedule View Document Order Setting Case Schedule
• 15 04/08/2020 Affidavit Declaration Certificate Confirmation of Service View Document Affidavit Declaration Certificate Confirmation of Service
• 16 06/09/2020 Declaration Affidavit View Document Declaration AffidavitComment
  Plaintiff’s of Fact Witnesses
• 17 06/09/2020 Disclosure View Document DisclosureComment
  Defendant’s Fact Witnesses
• 18 07/08/2020 Disclosure View Document Disclosure Comment
  Plaintiff’s of Expert Witnesses
• 19 07/29/2020 Disclosure View Document Disclosure Comment
  Defendant’s Expert Witnesses
• 20 09/02/2020 Disclosure View Document Disclosure Comment
  Defendant’s Rebuttal Witnesses
• 21 09/08/2020 Disclosure View Document Disclosure Comment
  Plaintiff’s Expert Witnesses
• 22 09/22/2020 Disclosure View Document Disclosure Comment
  Plaintiff’s Supplemental Fact Witnesses
• 23 10/07/2020 Order Striking View Document Order Striking Comment
  Trial Date and Scheduling New Trial Setting Date
• 24 10/07/2020 Affidavit Declaration Certificate Confirmation of Service View Document Affidavit Declaration Certificate Confirmation of Service
• 25 10/08/2020 Response View Document Response Comment
  Scheduling Questionnaire
• 26 10/09/2020 Response View Document Response Comment
  Scheduling Questionnaire
• 27 10/09/2020 Notice of Absence Unavailability View Document Notice of Absence Unavailability
• 10/23/2020 Assignment for Trial Setting Judicial Officer
  Murphy, Carol Hearing Time
  9:00 AM
• 28 11/10/2020 Order Setting Case Schedule View Document Order Setting Case Schedule
• 29 11/10/2020 Affidavit Declaration Certificate Confirmation of Service View Document Affidavit Declaration Certificate Confirmation of Service
• 03/05/2021 Pre-Trial Conference Judicial Officer
  Murphy, Carol Hearing Time
  9:00 AM Cancel Reason
  Stricken
• 04/12/2021 Jury Trial Judicial Officer
  Murphy, Carol Hearing Time
  8:30 AM Cancel Reason
  Stricken
• 30 07/19/2021 Offer of Judgment View Document Offer of Judgment
• 31 09/10/2021 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings
• 32 09/10/2021 Declaration Affidavit View Document Declaration Affidavit Comment
  Morgan P Cartwright
• 33 09/10/2021 Motion for Summary Judgment View Document Motion for Summary Judgment Comment
  Partial
• 34 09/10/2021 Notice of Hearing View Document Notice of Hearing Comment
  Plaintiff’s Partial Summary Judgment
• 35 09/27/2021 Response View Document Response Comment
  Thurston County’s to Motion for Partial Summary Judgment
• 36 09/27/2021 Declaration Affidavit View Document Declaration Affidavit Comment
  of Cameron Schick M.D.
• 37 09/27/2021 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings
• 38 09/27/2021 Declaration Affidavit View Document Declaration Affidavit Comment
  of Samuel Ben Behar
• 39 09/27/2021 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings
• 40 09/28/2021 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings
• 41 10/01/2021 Order View Document Order Comment
  Regarding Scheduled Civil Motion
• 42 10/01/2021 Reply View Document Reply
• 43 10/01/2021 Affidavit Declaration Certificate Confirmation of Service View Document Affidavit Declaration Certificate Confirmation of Service
• 44 10/05/2021 Notice of Hearing View Document Notice of Hearing Comment
  Motion to Quash
• 45 10/05/2021 Motion View Document Motion Comment
  Thurston County’s to Quash Plaintiff’s Notice of Deposition and Subpoena
• 46 10/05/2021 Declaration Affidavit View Document Declaration Affidavit Comment
  of Samuel Ben Behar
• 47 10/05/2021 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings
• 48 10/05/2021 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings
• 49 10/05/2021 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings
• 50 10/07/2021 Defendants ER904 Notice View Document Defendants ER904 Notice
• 10/08/2021 Summary Judgment Judicial Officer
  Murphy, Carol Hearing Time
  9:00 AM Comment
  Plaintiff’s Partial – Parties Appearing via Zoom at 10:30
• 51 10/08/2021 Motion Hearing View Document Motion Hearing
• 52 10/11/2021 Affidavit Declaration Certificate Confirmation of Service View Document Affidavit Declaration Certificate Confirmation of Service
• 53 10/11/2021 Order View Document Order Comment
  Regarding Scheduled Civil Motion
• 54 10/14/2021 Notice of Association of Counsel View Document Notice of Association of Counsel
• 55 10/14/2021 Notice of Appearance View Document Notice of Appearance
• 10/15/2021 Pre-Trial Conference Judicial Officer
  Murphy, Carol Hearing Time
  9:00 AM Comment
  Zoom @ 10:00
• 56 10/15/2021 PreTrial Management Hearing View Document PreTrial Management Hearing
• 57 10/15/2021 Order on PreTrial Conference View Document Order on PreTrial Conference Comment
  Pretrial Conference
• 58 10/15/2021 Disclosure View Document Disclosure Comment
  Plaintiff’s Documents Pursuant to ER 904(b)
• 59 10/18/2021 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings
• 60 10/20/2021 Objection Opposition View Document Objection Opposition Comment
  Defendants to ER 904
• 61 10/20/2021 Objection Opposition View Document Objection Opposition Comment
  Plaintiff’s to ER 904
• 62 10/21/2021 Order Denying Motion Petition View Document Order Denying Motion Petition
• 63 10/26/2021 Declaration Affidavit View Document Declaration Affidavit Comment
  of Morgan P. Cartwright
• 64 10/26/2021 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings
• 65 10/26/2021 Response View Document Response Comment
  Plaintiff’s to Motion to Quash
• 66 10/26/2021 Notice Striking Hearing View Document Notice Striking Hearing
• 67 10/29/2021 Motion Hearing Judicial Officer
  Murphy, Carol Hearing Time
  9:00 AM Cancel Reason
  Stricken Comment
  Quash
• 10/29/2021 Pre-Trial Conference Judicial Officer
  Murphy, Carol Hearing Time
  9:00 AM
• 68 10/29/2021 Motion Hearing View Document Motion HearingComment
  All Pretrial Motions
• 69 10/29/2021 Disclosure View Document Disclosure Comment
  of Plaintiff’s Fact Witnesses (Second Supplemental)
• 70 10/29/2021 Motion in Limine View Document Motion in Limine Comment
  of Thurston County
• 71 10/29/2021 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings
• 72 10/29/2021 Motion in Limine View Document Motion in Limine Comment
  of Thurston County
• 73 10/29/2021 Motion in Limine View Document Motion in Limine Comment
  of Thurston County
• 74 10/29/2021 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings
• 75 11/01/2021 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings
• 76 11/01/2021 Motion in Limine View Document Motion in Limine Comment
  Plaintiff’s
• 77 11/02/2021 Response View Document Response
• 78 11/02/2021 Declaration Affidavit View Document Declaration Affidavit Comment
  of Morgan P. Cartwright
• 79 11/02/2021 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings
• 80 11/02/2021 Plaintiff Petitioner Brief View Document Plaintiff Petitioner Brief
• 81 11/03/2021 Response View Document Response Comment
  Thurston County’s to Plaintiff’s Motions in Limine
• 82 11/03/2021 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings
• 83 11/03/2021 Notice of Hearing View Document Notice of Hearing Comment
  Motion to Exclude the Preservation Deposition – Calendar Closed, Attorney Notified
• 84 11/03/2021 Motion View Document Motion Comment
  Defendant’s to Exclude the Preservation Deposition of Dr. McKay
• 85 11/03/2021 Reply View Document Reply
• 86 11/03/2021 Declaration Affidavit View Document Declaration AffidavitComment
  of Samuel Ben Behar
• 87 11/04/2021 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings
• 88 11/04/2021 Declaration Affidavit View Document Declaration Affidavit Comment
  of Morgan P. Cartwright
• 89 11/04/2021 Response View Document Response Comment
  Plaintiff’s Response to Defendant’s Motion to Exclude
• 11/05/2021 Motion Hearing Judicial Officer
  Murphy, CarolHearing Time
  9:00 AM Comment
  All Pretrial Motions
• 90 11/05/2021 Motion Hearing View Document Motion Hearing Comment
  Assignment for Trial Setting
• 11/15/2021 Jury Trial Judicial Officer
  Murphy, Carol Hearing Time
  8:30 AM Cancel Reason
  Stricken Comment
  4 Days
• 91 12/02/2021 Response View Document ResponseComment
  Scheduling Questionnaire
• 92 12/03/2021 Response View Document Response Comment
  Scheduling Questionnaire
• 93 12/08/2021 Response View Document Response Comment
  Scheduling Questionnaire
• 12/10/2021 Assignment for Trial Setting Judicial Officer
  Murphy, Carol Hearing Time
  9:00 AM
• 94 12/13/2021 Order Setting Case Schedule View Document Order Setting Case Schedule
• 95 12/13/2021 Affidavit Declaration Certificate Confirmation of Service View Document Affidavit Declaration Certificate Confirmation of Service
• 96 03/01/2022 Disclosure View Document DisclosureComment
  Plaintiff’s Fact Witnesses
• 97 03/11/2022 Offer of Judgment View Document Offer of Judgment Comment
  Defendant
• 98 03/30/2022 Disclosure View Document Disclosure Comment
  Defendant’s Expert Witnesses
• 99 04/01/2022 Disclosure View Document Disclosure Comment
  Plaintiff’s Expert Weitnesses
• 100 05/12/2022 Disclosure View Document Disclosure Comment
  Def Rebuttal Witnesses
• 101 05/16/2022 Disclosure View Document Disclosure Comment
  of Plaintiff’s Rebuttal Witnesses
• 102 08/22/2022 Notice View Document Notice Comment
  Plaintiff’s of Request for Virtual Pre-Trial Conference
• 09/16/2022 Pre-Trial Conference Judicial Officer
  Murphy, Carol Hearing Time
  9:00 AM
• 103 09/16/2022 Order on PreTrial Conference View Document Order on PreTrial Conference
• 104 09/16/2022 PreTrial Management Hearing View Document PreTrial Management Hearing
• 105 09/20/2022 Disclosure View Document Disclosure Comment
  Defendant’s Witnesses and Exhibits
• 106 09/23/2022 Declaration Affidavit View Document Declaration Affidavit Comment
  of Morgan P. Cartwright
• 107 09/23/2022 Notice of Hearing View Document Notice of Hearing Comment
  Motion on Perpetuation Deposition Objections
• 108 09/23/2022 Plaintiff Petitioner Brief View Document Plaintiff Petitioner Brief
• 109 09/23/2022 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings
• 110 09/29/2022 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings Comment
  Cover Sheet
• 111 09/29/2022 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings
• 112 09/29/2022 Motion View Document Motion Comment
  to Allow Non-Live Witnesses (Stipulated)
• 113 10/03/2022 Declaration Affidavit View Document Declaration Affidavit Comment
  Defendant’s Proposed Voir Dire
• 114 10/03/2022 Statement View Document Statement Comment
  Joint Statement of Evidence
• 115 10/04/2022 Motion in Limine View Document Motion in Limine Comment
  Thurston County’s
• 116 10/04/2022 Motion in Limine View Document Motion in Limine Comment
  Plaintiff’s
• 117 10/04/2022 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings
• 118 10/05/2022 Notice of Hearing View Document Notice of Hearing Comment
  Motions in Limine
• 119 10/05/2022 Response View Document Response Comment
  Defendant to Plntf Mt on Perpetuation Testimony Objections
• 120 10/05/2022 Notice of Hearing View Document Notice of Hearing Comment
  Plaintiff’s Motions in Limine
• 121 10/05/2022 Order View Document Order Comment
  re: Stipulated Motion to Allow Non-Live Witnesses
• 10/05/2022 Ex Parte Action With Order
• 10/07/2022 Motion Hearing Judicial Officer
  Murphy, Carol Hearing Time
  9:00 AM Comment
  on Perpetuation Deposition Objections
• 10/07/2022 Motion Hearing Judicial Officer
  Murphy, Carol Hearing Time
  9:00 AM Comment
  Allow Non-Live Witnesses
• 122 10/07/2022 Motion Hearing View Document Motion Hearing
• 123 10/10/2022 Trial Brief View Document Trial Brief Comment
  Plaintiff’s – Final Witness List and Witness Order
• 124 10/11/2022 Response View Document Response Comment
  of Thurston County to Motions in Limine
• 125 10/11/2022 Response View Document Response Comment
  Plaintiff’s to Defendant’s Motions in Limine
• 126 10/11/2022 Declaration Affidavit View Document Declaration Affidavit Comment
  of Morgan P. Cartwright in Support of Plaintiff’s Response
• 127 10/12/2022 Reply View Document Reply Comment
  to Motions in Limine – Plaintiff’s
• 128 10/12/2022 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings
• 10/14/2022 Motion in Limine Judicial Officer
  Murphy, Carol Hearing Time
  9:00 AM
• 10/14/2022 Motion in Limine Judicial Officer
  Murphy, Carol Hearing Time
  9:00 AM Comment
  Plaintiff’s
• 129 10/14/2022 Motion Hearing View Document Motion Hearing
• 10/17/2022 Jury Trial Judicial Officer
  Murphy, Carol Hearing Time
  8:30 AM Comment
  4 days
• 130 11/28/2022 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings Comment
  Re New Trial Date
• 131 12/06/2022 Order View Document Order Comment
  Regarding New Trial Date
• 12/06/2022 Ex Parte Action With Order
• 132 05/02/2023 Disclosure View Document Disclosure Comment
  Defendant’s- of Fact Witnesses
• 133 05/05/2023 Disclosure View Document Disclosure Comment
  Plaintiff’s Third Supplemental Fact Witnesses
• 134 06/05/2023 Disclosure View Document Disclosure Comment
  Plaintiff’s of Expert Witnesses
• 11/03/2023 Pre-Trial Conference Judicial Officer
  Murphy, Carol Hearing Time
  9:00 AM
• 135 11/03/2023 Order on PreTrial Conference View Document Order on PreTrial Conference
• 136 11/03/2023 PreTrial Management Hearing View Document PreTrial Management Hearing
• 137 11/03/2023 Disclosure View Document Disclosure Comment
  of Plaintiff RE Documents Pursuant to ER 904(b)
• 138 11/03/2023 Witness List View Document Witness List Comment
  List of Plaintiff
• 139 11/03/2023 Defendants ER904 Notice View Document Defendants ER904 Notice
• 140 11/06/2023 Order Modifying View Document Order Modifying Comment
  Starting Time of Jury Trial – SESSION NEEDED
• 11/06/2023 Ex Parte Action With Order
• 141 11/09/2023 Motion View Document Motion Comment
  to Allow Non-live Witnesses
• 142 11/09/2023 Joint Statement of Evidence View Document Joint Statement of Evidence Comment
  Amended
• 143 11/13/2023 Objection Opposition View Document Objection OppositionComment
  to Plaintiff ER904
• 144 11/13/2023 Motion in Limine View Document Motion in Limine
• 145 11/15/2023 Objection Opposition View Document Objection Opposition Comment
  to Defendant’s ER 904
• 146 11/16/2023 Order Denying Motion Petition View Document Order Denying Motion Petition
• 11/16/2023 Ex Parte Action With Order
• 147 11/17/2023 Motion in Limine View Document Motion in Limine Comment
  Plaintiff
• 148 11/21/2023 Plaintiff Petitioner Brief View Document Plaintiff Petitioner Brief Comment
  — Trial Brief, Witness List, and Witness Order
• 149 11/21/2023 Statement View Document Statement Comment
  Neutral
• 150 11/21/2023 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings
• 151 11/22/2023 Joint Statement of Evidence View Document Joint Statement of Evidence Comment
  Seond Amended
• 152 11/27/2023 Declaration Affidavit View Document Declaration Affidavit Comment
  of Samuel Ben Behar
• 153 11/27/2023 Response View Document Response Comment
  of Defendant to Motions in Limine
• 154 11/28/2023 Motion View Document Motion Comment
  to Allow Preservation Deposition Testimony
• 155 11/28/2023 Proposed Order Findings View Document Proposed Order Findings
• 156 11/28/2023 Order Granting Motion Petition View Document Order Granting Motion Petition Comment
  re: Motion on Preservation
• 11/28/2023 Ex Parte Action With Order
• 157 11/29/2023 Response View Document Response Comment
  Plaintiff’s – re: Defendant’s Motions of Limine (E&J)
• 158 11/29/2023 Reply View Document Reply Comment
  Plaintiff’s – re: Defendant’s Motion in Limine (1-14)
• 159 11/29/2023 Receipt for Exhibits or Unopened Depositions View Document Receipt for Exhibits or Unopened Depositions Comment
  Unused Exhibits
• 160 11/29/2023 Order Granting Motion Petition View Document Order Granting Motion Petition Comment
  to Allow Preservation Deposition Testimony
• 11/29/2023 Ex Parte Action With Order
• 161 11/29/2023 Brief View Document Brief Comment
  Defendant’s Proposed Vior Dire
• 162 11/30/2023 Brief View Document Brief Comment
  Plaintiff’s Proposed Vior Dire
• 163 12/01/2023 Order View Document Order Comment
  Granting in Part and Denying in Part Motion on Preservation Deposition
• 12/01/2023 Ex Parte Action With Order
• 164 12/01/2023 Instructions View Document Instructions Comment
  Agreed – Jury, w/Citations
• 165 12/01/2023 Instructions View Document Instructions Comment
  Duplicate
• 166 12/01/2023 Plaintiffs Proposed Instructions View Document Plaintiffs Proposed Instructions Comment
  w/Citations
• 12/01/2023 Plaintiffs Proposed Instructions Comment
  Duplicate
• 167 12/01/2023 Notice View Document Notice Comment
  Plaintiff’s Proposed Vior Dire
• 168 12/01/2023 Brief View Document Brief Comment
  and Final Witness List
• 169 12/01/2023 Defendants Proposed Instructions View Document Defendants Proposed Instructions Comment
  Cited
• 170 12/01/2023 Defendants Proposed Instructions View Document Defendants Proposed Instructions Comment
  Uncited
• 171 12/01/2023 Courts Instructions to Jury View Document Courts Instructions to Jury
• 172 12/01/2023 Plaintiffs Proposed Instructions View Document Plaintiffs Proposed Instructions Comment
  Uncited
• 12/04/2023 Jury Trial Judicial Officer
  Murphy, Carol Hearing Time
  1:30 AM
• 12/04/2023 Jury Trial Judicial Officer
  Murphy, Carol Hearing Time
  9:00 AM Cancel Reason
  Continuance
• 12/04/2023 Jury Trial